Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
SNL Cast Member Knockout
#1
Don't think we've done this before.  I cut out anyone who only lasted 1-2 seasons (except for Chevy), or pretty much only did Update (so no to Che and Jost) aand trimmed a couple of obvious deadweights (sorry Gary Kroeger and Tim Kazurinsky).  It's still a big list.

Anyway, you all know the rules.  3 votes per day, non-consecutive.

TUES 1

+ Jan Hooks
-  Melanie Hutsell


3  Fred Armisen
3  Dan Akroyd
3  Vanessa Bayer
3  John Belushi
3  Beck Bennet
3  Jim Breuer
3  Aidy Bryant
3  Dana Carvey 
3  Chevy Chase
3  Ellen Cleghorne
3  Jane Curtin
3  Pete Davidson
3  Mikey Day
3  Rachel Dratch
3  Nora Dunn
3  Jimmy Fallon
3  Chris Farley
3  Will Ferrell
3  Tina Fey
3  Will Forte
3  Al Franken
3  Ana Gasteyer
3  Bill Hader
3  Darrell Hammond
3  Phil Hartman 
4  Jan Hooks
2  Melanie Hutsell
3  Victoria Jackson
3  Leslie Jones
3  Chris Kattan
3  Taran Killam
3  Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3  Jon Lovitz
3  Norm MacDonald
3  Mark McKinney
3  Kate McKinnon
3  Tim Meadows
3  Dennis Miller
3  Alex Moffat
3  Kyle Mooney
3  Tracy Morgan
3  Garrett Morris
3  Bobby Moynihan
3  Eddie Murphy
3  Bill Murray
3  Mike Myers
3  Kevin Nealon
3  Laraine Newman
3  Cheri Oteri
3  Chris Parnell
3  Nasim Pedrad
3  Jay Pharoah
3  Joe Piscopo
3  Amy Poehler
3  Colin Quinn
3  Gilda Radner
3  Chris Rock
3  Maya Rudolph
3  Andy Samberg
3  Adam Sandler
3  Horatio Sanz
3  Rob Schneider
3  Molly Shannon
3  David Spade 
3  Cecily Strong
3  Jason Sudeikis
3  Julia Sweeney
3  Kenan Thompson
3  Melissa Villasenor
3  Kristen Wiig
3  Sasheer Zamata
Reply
#2
Norm +1
Pete Davidson -1

3  Fred Armisen
3  Dan Akroyd
3  Vanessa Bayer
3  John Belushi
3  Beck Bennet
3  Jim Breuer
3  Aidy Bryant
3  Dana Carvey 
3  Chevy Chase
3  Ellen Cleghorne
3  Jane Curtin
2  Pete Davidson
3  Mikey Day
3  Rachel Dratch
3  Nora Dunn
3  Jimmy Fallon
3  Chris Farley
3  Will Ferrell
3  Tina Fey
3  Will Forte
3  Al Franken
3  Ana Gasteyer
3  Bill Hader
3  Darrell Hammond
3  Phil Hartman 
4  Jan Hooks
2  Melanie Hutsell
3  Victoria Jackson
3  Leslie Jones
3  Chris Kattan
3  Taran Killam
3  Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3  Jon Lovitz
4  Norm MacDonald
3  Mark McKinney
3  Kate McKinnon
3  Tim Meadows
3  Dennis Miller
3  Alex Moffat
3  Kyle Mooney
3  Tracy Morgan
3  Garrett Morris
3  Bobby Moynihan
3  Eddie Murphy
3  Bill Murray
3  Mike Myers
3  Kevin Nealon
3  Laraine Newman
3  Cheri Oteri
3  Chris Parnell
3  Nasim Pedrad
3  Jay Pharoah
3  Joe Piscopo
3  Amy Poehler
3  Colin Quinn
3  Gilda Radner
3  Chris Rock
3  Maya Rudolph
3  Andy Samberg
3  Adam Sandler
3  Horatio Sanz
3  Rob Schneider
3  Molly Shannon
3  David Spade 
3  Cecily Strong
3  Jason Sudeikis
3  Julia Sweeney
3  Kenan Thompson
3  Melissa Villasenor
3  Kristen Wiig
3  Sasheer Zamata
Reply
#3
Phil Hartman +1
Sasheer Zamata -1 (she's talented, but they didn't let her do anything on the show)

3 Fred Armisen
3 Dan Akroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
3 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
3 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
2 Pete Davidson
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
3 Ana Gasteyer
3 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
4 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Melanie Hutsell
3 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
3 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
4 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
3 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
3 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
3 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
3 Colin Quinn
3 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
3 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
3 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata
Reply
#4
Phil Hartman +1
Pete Davidson -1

3 Fred Armisen
3 Dan Akroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
3 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
3 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
1 Pete Davidson
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
3 Ana Gasteyer
3 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
5 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Melanie Hutsell
3 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
3 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
4 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
3 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
3 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
3 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
3 Colin Quinn
3 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
3 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
3 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata
Reply
#5
I kinda disagree with the non-inclusion of Tim Kazurinsky. He was on for many seasons and was used quite a bit in many sketches. I think he merits inclusion, even if I'd be totally fine with him being in the bottom 10% of the list.

Also, if I had my way, I'd just put the 1984-85 year at the top and call it a day. That Crystal/Guest/Shearer year will simply never be topped in terms of being consistently funny.

+1 Ana Gasteyer
-1 Chris Kattan

3 Fred Armisen
3 Dan Akroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
3 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
3 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
1 Pete Davidson
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
4 Ana Gasteyer
3 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
5 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Melanie Hutsell
3 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
4 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
3 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
3 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
3 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
3 Colin Quinn
3 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
3 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
3 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata
Reply
#6
WED First


+ Tim Meadows (he's only gotten funnier post-SNL, but he was underrated glue for the Farley/Sandler/Rock years)
KO Pete Davidson (I know, he's some sort of hero for joking about his mental illness on TV.  What he is not is a funny sketch performer)

3 Fred Armisen
3 Dan Akroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
3 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
3 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
K0  Pete Davidson
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
4 Ana Gasteyer
3 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
5 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Melanie Hutsell
3 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
4 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
3 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
3 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
3 Colin Quinn
3 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
3 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
3 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata


SOCIALS DELETED

71.  Pete Davidson
Reply
#7
Davidson going out before Melanie Hutsell is amazing.
Reply
#8
Norm +1
Horatio Sanz -1

3 Fred Armisen
3 Dan Akroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
3 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
3 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
4 Ana Gasteyer
3 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
5 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Melanie Hutsell
3 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
5 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
3 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
3 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
3 Colin Quinn
3 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
2 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
3 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata


SOCIALS DELETED

71.  Pete Davidson
Reply
#9
+1 Ana Gasteyer
-1 Melanie Hutsell

3 Fred Armisen
3 Dan Akroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
3 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
3 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
3 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
5 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
1 Melanie Hutsell
3 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
5 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
3 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
3 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
3 Colin Quinn
3 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
2 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
3 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata


SOCIALS DELETED

71. Pete Davidson
Reply
#10
[quote pid='4576989' dateline='1546445795']
WED 2

+ Chris Parnell  (also underrated, but a key part to a lot of classic sketches)
KO  Melanie Hutsell

3 Fred Armisen
3 Dan Akroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
3 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
3 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
3 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
5 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
3 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
5 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
3 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
3 Colin Quinn
3 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
2 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
3 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata


FACE GOT STUCK THAT WAY

70.  Melanie Hutsell
71.  Pete Davidson
[/quote]
Reply
#11
[quote pid='4576989' dateline='1546445795']
WED 2

+ Chris Parnell  (also underrated, but a key part to a lot of classic sketches)
KO  Melanie Hutsell

3 Fred Armisen
3 Dan Akroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
3 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
3 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
3 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
5 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
3 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
5 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
3 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
3 Colin Quinn
3 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
2 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
3 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata


FACE GOT STUCK THAT WAY

70.  Melanie Hutsell
71.  Pete Davidson
[/quote]
Reply
#12
Dirty little secret: I laughed at Hutsell's Jan Brady way back when.

Norm +1
Horatio Sanz -1

3 Fred Armisen
3 Dan Akroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
3 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
3 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
3 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
5 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
3 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
6 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
3 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
3 Colin Quinn
3 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
3 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata


FACE GOT STUCK THAT WAY

70.  Melanie Hutsell
71.  Pete Davidson
Reply
#13
Hutsel's Jan Brady was kind fun. But she's one note. Hartman is, I believe, pound-for-pound the greatest overall cast member. But I'm gonna spread my love around a bit. You millenial whippersnappers have no idea how goddamned funny Dana Carvey was in his prime. Also, speaking of one-note, fuck Jim Bruer.


Carvey +1
Bruer -1

3 Fred Armisen
3 Dan Akroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
3 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
5 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
3 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
6 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
3 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
3 Colin Quinn
3 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
3 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata


FACE GOT STUCK THAT WAY

70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
If you're happy, you're not paying attention.

Originally Posted by JacknifeJohnny: 
Glad that you guys worked that out amongst yourselves.

Reply
#14
Norm +1
Jimmy Fallon -1

3 Fred Armisen
3 Dan Akroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
2 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
3 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
5 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
3 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
7 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
3 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
3 Colin Quinn
3 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
3 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata


FACE GOT STUCK THAT WAY

70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Reply
#15
+1 Dan Akroyd
-1 Victoria Jackson


3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Akroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
3 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
5 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
6 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
3 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
3 Colin Quinn
3 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
3 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata


FACE GOT STUCK THAT WAY

70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
"Lets pour some sugar on Dallas!!  Seriose inquarys only!"
Reply
#16
+1 Gilda Radner
-1 Alex Moffat (WHO?)

3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Akroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
3 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
5 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
6 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
2 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
3 Colin Quinn
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
3 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata


FACE GOT STUCK THAT WAY

70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Reply
#17
(01-02-2019, 02:23 PM)Neil Spurn Wrote: Hutsel's Jan Brady was kind fun.  But she's one note.  Hartman is, I believe, pound-for-pound the greatest overall cast member.  But I'm gonna spread my love around a bit.  You millenial whippersnappers have no idea how goddamned funny Dana Carvey was in his prime. Also, speaking of one-note, fuck Jim Bruer.

Hutsell's Jan Brady face is the entirety of her one note, and it's pretty excruciating.  

I fully expect Hartman to end with the most votes, but right now he's so safe that no one is going to bother for a bit.

Breuer had Goat Boy, the Joe Pesci show and Wong and Owens: Ex-Porn Stars.  That's more than quite a few of these folks can hang their hats on.

Alex Moffat does the childlike Eric Trump, Joe Scarborough, and has been a very solid utility player for the last couple years. He deserves to beat at least 10 remaining options.
Reply
#18
Was Franken ever a regular cast member?

+1 Cecily Strong
-1  Colin Quinn

3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Aykroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
3 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
5 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
6 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
2 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
2 Colin Quinn
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
4 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata


FACE GOT STUCK THAT WAY

70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
"I'd rather wake up in the middle of nowhere than in any city on Earth."--Steve McQueen
Reply
#19
Just doing a reset because my votes from post #14 haven't been included in the last few posts:

3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Aykroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
2 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
3 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
5 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
7 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
2 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
2 Colin Quinn
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
4 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata


FACE GOT STUCK THAT WAY

70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Reply
#20
WED Final

+ Bill Hader
- Colin Quinn


3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Aykroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
4 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
5 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
6 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
2 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
1 Colin Quinn
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
4 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata


FACE GOT STUCK THAT WAY

70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Reply
#21
+ Phil Hartman
- Alex Moffat


3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Aykroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
3 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
4 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
6 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
6 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
1 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
3 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
1 Colin Quinn
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
4 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata


FACE GOT STUCK THAT WAY

70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Reply
#22
WED first:

+1 John Belushi
-1 Cheri Oteri


3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Aykroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
4 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
3 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
4 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
6 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
6 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
1 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
2 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
1 Colin Quinn
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
4 Cecily Strong
3 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata


FACE GOT STUCK THAT WAY

70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Giving money to the studio that keeps enabling Adam Sandler is morally equivalent to Satanic kitten rape orgies. - Hypnotoad
Reply
#23
Y'all being too harsh on Alex Moffat.  He's got a couple of good characters and he can make it through a single line in a live sketch without flubbing it, which puts him well ahead of Colin Quinn or Leslie Jones at the least.
Reply
#24
+ Chris Farley
- Jason Sudeikis

3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Aykroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
4 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
4 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
4 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
6 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
6 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
1 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
2 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
1 Colin Quinn
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
3 David Spade
4 Cecily Strong
2 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata

MAD TV STILL HIRING?

70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Reply
#25
David Spade +
Cheri Oteri -

3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Aykroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
4 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
4 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
4 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
6 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
6 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
1 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
1 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
1 Colin Quinn
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
4 David Spade
4 Cecily Strong
2 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata

MAD TV STILL HIRING?

70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Brigadier Cousins on PSN
Reply
#26
THUR 1

+ Cheri Oteri
KO Colin Quinn

3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Aykroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
4 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
4 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
5 Ana Gasteyer
4 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
6 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
2 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
6 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
1 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
2 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
4 David Spade
4 Cecily Strong
2 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata

GRUMBLE GRUMBLE SOMETHING....JOKE?

69. Colin Quinn
70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Reply
#27
+1 Ana Gasteyer
-1 Chris Kattan


3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Aykroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
4 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
3 Jimmy Fallon
4 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
6 Ana Gasteyer
4 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
6 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
1 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
6 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
1 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
2 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
4 David Spade
4 Cecily Strong
2 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata

GRUMBLE GRUMBLE SOMETHING....JOKE?

69. Colin Quinn 
70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Reply
#28
I'm working my vote from post #14 yesterday (+Norm, -Fallon) into these totals:

Norm +1
Jimmy Fallon -1


3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Aykroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
4 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
1 Jimmy Fallon
4 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
6 Ana Gasteyer
4 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
6 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
1 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
8 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
1 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
2 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
4 David Spade
4 Cecily Strong
2 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata

GRUMBLE GRUMBLE SOMETHING....JOKE?

69. Colin Quinn 
70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Reply
#29
-1 Jim Breuer
+1 Amy Poehler

3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Aykroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
4 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
1 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
1 Jimmy Fallon
4 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
6 Ana Gasteyer
4 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
6 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
3 Leslie Jones
1 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
8 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
1 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
2 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
4 Amy Poehler
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
4 David Spade
4 Cecily Strong
2 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata

GRUMBLE GRUMBLE SOMETHING....JOKE?

69. Colin Quinn
70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Reply
#30
THUR 2

+ Alex Moffat (I'll throw him one vote at least, just for his mannerisms as Eric Trump)
- Leslie Jones

3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Aykroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
4 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
1 Jimmy Fallon
4 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
6 Ana Gasteyer
4 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
6 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
2 Leslie Jones
1 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
8 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
2 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
2 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
4 David Spade
4 Cecily Strong
2 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata

GRUMBLE GRUMBLE SOMETHING....JOKE?

69. Colin Quinn
70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Reply
#31
Norm +1
Bobby Moynihan -1

3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Aykroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
4 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
1 Jimmy Fallon
4 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
6 Ana Gasteyer
4 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
6 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
2 Leslie Jones
1 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
9 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
2 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
2 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
2 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
4 David Spade
4 Cecily Strong
2 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata

GRUMBLE GRUMBLE SOMETHING....JOKE?

69. Colin Quinn
70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Reply
#32
Moynihan is easily in the top half of this group, Molt. Sober up.

THUR 3

+ Bobby Moynihan
- Leslie Jones

3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Aykroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
4 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
1 Jimmy Fallon
4 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
6 Ana Gasteyer
4 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
6 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
1 Leslie Jones
1 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
9 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
2 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
2 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
1 Horatio Sanz
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
4 David Spade
4 Cecily Strong
2 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata

GRUMBLE GRUMBLE SOMETHING....JOKE?

69. Colin Quinn
70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Reply
#33
(01-03-2019, 05:00 PM)schwartz Wrote: Moynihan is easily in the top half of this group, Molt.  Sober up.

Anyone from the last 12 years or so I'm at a disadvantage with. By in large I've only seen these people in clips online and nothing I saw from Moynihan led to much in the way of chortles. The couple Drunk Uncle bits I've caught are okay but seems like a character that if you've seen in a couple segments you've seen it all.

I can buy that he should get a reprieve for now but there is no chance he should make the top half.

Hartman +1
Horatio Sanz KO

3 Fred Armisen
4 Dan Aykroyd
3 Vanessa Bayer
4 John Belushi
3 Beck Bennet
2 Jim Breuer
3 Aidy Bryant
4 Dana Carvey
3 Chevy Chase
3 Ellen Cleghorne
3 Jane Curtin
3 Mikey Day
3 Rachel Dratch
3 Nora Dunn
1 Jimmy Fallon
4 Chris Farley
3 Will Ferrell
3 Tina Fey
3 Will Forte
3 Al Franken
6 Ana Gasteyer
4 Bill Hader
3 Darrell Hammond
7 Phil Hartman
4 Jan Hooks
2 Victoria Jackson
1 Leslie Jones
1 Chris Kattan
3 Taran Killam
3 Julia Louis-Dreyfus
3 Jon Lovitz
9 Norm MacDonald
3 Mark McKinney
3 Kate McKinnon
4 Tim Meadows
3 Dennis Miller
2 Alex Moffat
3 Kyle Mooney
3 Tracy Morgan
3 Garrett Morris
3 Bobby Moynihan
3 Eddie Murphy
3 Bill Murray
3 Mike Myers
3 Kevin Nealon
3 Laraine Newman
2 Cheri Oteri
4 Chris Parnell
3 Nasim Pedrad
3 Jay Pharoah
3 Joe Piscopo
3 Amy Poehler
4 Gilda Radner
3 Chris Rock
3 Maya Rudolph
3 Andy Samberg
3 Adam Sandler
3 Rob Schneider
3 Molly Shannon
4 David Spade
4 Cecily Strong
2 Jason Sudeikis
3 Julia Sweeney
3 Kenan Thompson
3 Melissa Villasenor
3 Kristen Wiig
2 Sasheer Zamata

Gone boating:

68. Horatio Sanz
69. Colin Quinn
70. Melanie Hutsell
71. Pete Davidson
Reply
#34
Shame that Sanz isn't well regarded. I was never a regular viewer so I wouldn't know how he was on SNL but he's really funny whenever I hear him on podcasts.
I might have been born yesterday sir, but I stayed up all night!
Reply
#35
Right, it's an Update character.  They're entirely formulaic.  But Drunk Uncle is one of the better ones.  Riblet isn't bad either.  And his cow-eyed Brian Kilmeade is always good for a Chortle.
Sanz is fantastic improviser, but imo he never popped on SNL.  He was worse than Fallon when it came to breaking, and just always came off as super stoned.  Kind of like Pete Davidson, if Davidson actually appeared in sketches.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)