The Trouble City Forums
1930s Draft: Round One - Ratty vs. Bailey vs. EvilTwin - Printable Version

+- The Trouble City Forums (http://citizens.trouble.city)
+-- Forum: The Citizens (http://citizens.trouble.city/forumdisplay.php?fid=91)
+--- Forum: Drafts & Lists (http://citizens.trouble.city/forumdisplay.php?fid=43)
+--- Thread: 1930s Draft: Round One - Ratty vs. Bailey vs. EvilTwin (/showthread.php?tid=162782)



1930s Draft: Round One - Ratty vs. Bailey vs. EvilTwin - Pither - 06-30-2021

(06-07-2021, 05:24 PM)ratty Wrote: Ratty presents:

DEPRESSION? WHAT DEPRESSION?:  THE 1930S DRAFT

1.  THE ADVENTURES OF ROBIN HOOD (1938)

2.  BRINGING UP BABY (1938)

3.  FREAKS (1932)

4.  GONE WITH THE WIND (1939)

5.  THE OLD DARK HOUSE (1932)

BONUS:  MR. DEEDS GOES TO TOWN (1936)


(06-07-2021, 07:03 PM)bailey Wrote: Genre defining films & personal favorites

1. Duck Soup (1933) McCarey
[Image: 22jg.gif]

2. Stagecoach (1939) Ford
[Image: 208412.gif]

3. Only Angels Have Wings (1939) Hawks
[Image: f36561ddfd384c1cc8526770376881c7beded46e.gifv]

4. The 39 Steps (1935) Hitchcock
[Image: 4e514cedf559b859462072b79a95db59.gif]

5. Little Caesar (1931) LeRoy
[Image: AjZj.gif]

Bonus:
Bombshell (1933) Fleming
Vampyr (1932) Dreyer

(06-08-2021, 07:44 AM)eviltwin Wrote: Now With Sound!
There's No Business Like Show Business!

1. Gold Diggers of 1933 (1933) - Mervyn LeRoy & Busby Berkeley
[Image: Gold_Diggers_of_1933_%28window_card_-_cropped%29.jpg]

2. Swing Time (1936) - George Stevens
[Image: 4773d793-9195-4ce1-87ca-e4476b2f999d_1.3...nBg=ffffff]

3. She Done Him Wrong (1933) - Lowell Sherman
[Image: MV5BMzRiZmRmNTEtODZlYS00NzFkLTgxZWYtYmQ4...@._V1_.jpg]

4. Twentieth Century (1934) - Howard Hawks
[Image: MV5BMmQ2NjdhZjgtZTc4OC00NmIzLWFkOGYtZTJm...@._V1_.jpg]

5. FOOTLIGHT PARADE (1933) - Lloyd Bacon & Busby Berkeley
[Image: footlight-parade-poster.jpg?w=640]

Plus a Bonus Double Feature of Horror

DR. JEKYLL AND MR. HYDE (1931) - Rouben Mamoulian
[Image: R9dcadcd891ee3f34ed43c962c1fd9814?rik=tV...pid=ImgRaw]

MYSTERY OF THE WAX MUSEUM (1933) - Michael Curtiz
[Image: latest?cb=20171118152844]



RE: 1930s Draft: Round One - Ratty vs. Bailey vs. EvilTwin - Mangy - 07-01-2021

I think bailey's first 3 choices are 3 of the best movies of the decade, so I'm going to go with bailey.


RE: 1930s Draft: Round One - Ratty vs. Bailey vs. EvilTwin - Richard Dickson - 07-01-2021

These are all strong, but Ratty's got two of the titans of the decade plus solid picks all the way through.

VOTE: Ratty


RE: 1930s Draft: Round One - Ratty vs. Bailey vs. EvilTwin - Judas Booth - 07-02-2021

Ratty and bailey have several personal favorites of mine on their lists. Eviltwin has several films on his list that I've unfortunately never seen, so I don't feel that I can adequately judge his list compared to the others. My apologies, eviltwin, but I must go with one of the others.

Ratty has ROBIN HOOD and BRINGING UP BABY. Bailey has DUCK SOUP and STAGECOACH. The rest of their lists are impeccable as well. I have to choose one, though.

Vote: Ratty, for the simple fact that BRINGING UP BABY is a film that I wish I could have gotten for my own personal list of screwball comedies.


RE: 1930s Draft: Round One - Ratty vs. Bailey vs. EvilTwin - hp pufncraft - 07-02-2021

Bringing Up Baby is such a charming romantic comedy and Freaks is a horror classic. Ratty gets my vote.


RE: 1930s Draft: Round One - Ratty vs. Bailey vs. EvilTwin - simbob - 07-03-2021

I was bouncing back and forth between Ratty and eviltwin, but I'm going with eviltwin. Twin has three I was think of...one of which I actually picked and then had to go back and change after looking in the bonus thread.


RE: 1930s Draft: Round One - Ratty vs. Bailey vs. EvilTwin - Hot Sandwich - 07-07-2021

Ratty. Duck Soup is an all-time classic, but Ratty is hitting from all angles.